Hood Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Hood community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Hood Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Question

who's talking here?

Ashley =] 2
KellyP 1
Megz 1
Ich bin Batman 3
*That Girl* 1
Ktown Raised 1
Bananas 1
MsOpinionated 2
bonnienclyde2008 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Ashley =] --- 15 years ago -

Hi girls! I haven't been on this site in about a year and am not even stationed at Hood anymore but I have a general military question I'm hoping someone can give me advice on.

Here's the story.

There are two guys in my husbands unit that are over weight, repeatedly fail their PT tests and can't pass tape. Because these soldiers can't/won't lose weight, the whole unit is being punished. The punishment is that they have to wake up at 3am drive in the company van to Ft Rucker (appox. 70 miles) to do PT with their company.

My husband takes pride in the fact that he has never failed a PT and that he never has to worry about making tape. So now he works from 3am to 5pm and wants to go to bed by 6pm because he's exhausted. My 2 year old and I don't get to spend time with him anymore. I work too and now that he leaves so early in the morning I have had to tell my work to give me different hours (I work at a bank) to accommodate his crazy hours.

I don't understand why the whole unit (like 15 guys total) are being punished when they are doing what they need to do to pass their tests.

I want our life back. Who do I need to complain to? 

bonnienclyde2008 --- 15 years ago -

I would start with the Commander, if you don't get any results then the BN Commander and so on.... 

Ashley =] --- 15 years ago -

The commander is a dick! My husband an fellow soldiers have gone up the chain of command as far as IG! And I have contacted IG. No results. 

Bananas --- 15 years ago -

Those soldiers should be flagged already...the unit should have some sort of "special pt" program for soldiers. good luck, sounds like a mess 

Megz (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

unfortunately some units have the 'punish the unit as a whole' mindset with the thought process that if all the guys get punished enough they will beat the crap out of the screwups until they shape up. Sounds like your husbands unit is one of those. If IG doesnt work Im not sure what will. 

Ktown Raised --- 15 years ago -

JAG, contact them. One of the wives called JAG on our 1st SGT because he made it mandatory that all NCOs go to the ball, come to find out that it is illegal to make soldiers of any rank attend a military ball. So a lot of folks got their money back. As far as punishing the entire unit because of someone else's issues and what not, that is just plain crazy if you ask me. So call JAG and tell them about it. I swear people take their rank to an extreme. 

*That Girl* --- 15 years ago -

In my husbands unit they are just discharging people for that. you fail a test or pt, you get one more chance a week later and if you fail again they start the discharge. 

MsOpinionated --- 15 years ago -

not that I don't think that a soldier should have to pass a PT test, but sometimes commands really screw soldiers over by having them take a pt test a day after they get off profile after they've BEEN on profile for 6 months.. Gee you think a soldier that hasn't been allowed to exercise in cetain ways is going to be ABLE to pass a pt test.. then OR a week later.. lets be realistic, sometimes it just takes a little while to heal and get back up to speed. anyway, that is my personal rant.

as far as the situation goes.. I'd def be calling JAG. :) 

Ich bin Batman --- 15 years ago -

Unfortunately, the Army owns your husband. He agreed to that when he signed the contract, hence GI (Government Issue). They can tell him what to do, when they want, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Have him read up on AR 600-9, not that it will be much help to him, but you never know. 

Ich bin Batman --- 15 years ago -

In my husbands unit they are just discharging people for that. you fail a test or pt, you get one more chance a week later and if you fail again they start the discharge.

Check into AR 350-1 and AR 40-501. There is a regulation somewhere, and I'm not sure it is one of those above, that says they have XX amount of time to recover and be required to pass an APFT. But keep in mind, they do have to take a diagnostic APFT after being removed from the profile which is usually a commanders assessment tool to determine the unit's overall physical readiness.

Sorry, I don't know it all, LOL, my husband is sitting here quoting it all to me. I'm just out of surgery and if I were to say it on my own, it would make no sense with all the anesthesia inside of me.... 

bonnienclyde2008 --- 15 years ago -

None of the regulations listed here are going to assist with why her husband has to go in at 3 am now...i guess my question is this..did he not have to go to pt formation before?? or is the unit now requiring him to go into PT earlier? 

Ich bin Batman --- 15 years ago -

In my first response, I never said that one would help, I just said to look at it and "not that it will b e much help to him". I stated just that he is owned by the Army, as much as we all hate it, that is how it is with our Soldiers. The Army comes first...

My second response was to someone else on here who posted something, completely unrelated to what Ashley was asking. 

KellyP --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like a remote detached group of guys who are now being told they need to do PT with the entire unit at Rucker, you won't find anything illegal about that.
I really don't see what the problem or complaint is here. Call me mean here if you want, but most soldiers and families would kill to have hours as simple and short as 3am-5pm. 

MsOpinionated --- 15 years ago -

my hubby (we are flw) gets up at 3, to be there by 4 something to pt with privates, and sometimes he doesn't get off (not in winter so much but def in the summer) until 8pm. yeah it sucks hardcore, BUT he's not deployed so I can't complain too much. 

bonnienclyde2008 --- 15 years ago -

My old BN CSM had a policy that all NCO'S will be at the B's at 0400 to ensure that the soldiers were up and ready for PT at @ 0500 regardless of PT failures or overweight’s..I hate to say it but there is nothing in the regulation that says they can't enforce these policies..I know it sucks and it’s more time away from the family but to build unit cohesion and readiness, they do it..most of the time it’s a power thing, to show who's boss, but honestly it is the NCO of the soldier who is failings' responsibility to ensure there soldiers readiness..if the soldier isn’t passing PT test or hgt/wgt there NCO should be making sure that soldier gets to a nutritionist and is doing remedial PT daily, as well as monitoring the soldiers progress ( that is required according to regulation)...when NCO's are failing across the board then Commanders/1SG's enforce these policies to put fire under the NCO's as* and in the process everyone else in the unit takes the slack... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Hood Underground